The Gujarat Riots, “Empuraan,” and the Clash of Truth: How the Left’s Wordplay Outfoxes the Right’s Raw Honesty

On March 27, 2025, the Malayalam film L2: Empuraan hit theaters, shattering box office records with over Rs 100 crore worldwide in days. It also ignited a firestorm. The movie’s opening—a 30-minute depiction of communal riots echoing the 2002 Gujarat violence—drew blood from India’s political fault lines. Graphic scenes of Hindu mobs targeting Muslims, a character named Baba Bajrangi rising from riot leader to political power, and a narrative skewering right-wing governance turned it into a lightning rod. Right-wing groups—RSS, BJP supporters, and Hindutva voices—erupted, branding it “anti-Hindu propaganda,” calling for boycotts, and even demanding Mohanlal’s honorary military rank be revoked.

Meanwhile, the left hailed it as a bold truth-teller, with Kerala’s Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan defending its artistic freedom. By March 30, the filmmakers caved, cutting 17 scenes and issuing apologies. Box office aside, the controversy exposed a deeper war: the left’s mastery of narrative versus the right’s clumsy, honest fury—and how the latter keeps losing the optics game.

The Facts: Godhra and Gujarat, Unvarnished

Let’s start with the raw truth, no veil. On February 27, 2002, a Muslim mob torched the S-6 coach of the Sabarmati Express near Godhra, Gujarat. Fifty-nine Hindu karsevaks—pilgrims returning from Ayodhya—burned alive. The Nanavati-Mehta Commission (2008) ruled it premeditated, not spontaneous; 31 were convicted, mostly Muslims, with petrol as the weapon. This wasn’t a random scuffle—it was a slaughter that lit a fuse. What followed was a Hindu retaliation that didn’t stop at parity.

Over the next weeks, riots tore through Gujarat—1,044 dead per official counts, over 2,000 by independent estimates like Human Rights Watch, mostly Muslims. Mobs burned homes, killed families, and yes, committed rapes—like in Naroda Patiya, where courts later confirmed the carnage. Narendra Modi, then Gujarat’s Chief Minister, was accused of letting it happen; a 2012 Special Investigation Team cleared him, but the stench of complicity lingers in public memory.

Empuraan picks this scab. Reports say it lingers on the riots—Hindu aggression front and center—while barely nodding to Godhra’s 59 deaths. That’s not balance; it’s a choice. The film’s Baba Bajrangi mirrors Babu Bajrangi, a real Bajrang Dal leader jailed for the Naroda massacre, amplifying the jab at Hindu nationalists. The left cheers this as “historical courage”; the right sees a middle finger to their dead. Both are half-right, but the facts don’t bend: Godhra happened, Gujarat followed, and neither side’s hands are clean.

The Left’s Sly Game: Words as Weapons

Here’s where the left outsmarts the right. They don’t just tell stories—they frame them. Empuraan isn’t pitched as fiction; it’s sold as a mirror to “fascist” India, a critique of BJP’s Hindutva. The language is deliberate: “communal violence,” “minority oppression,” “right-wing tyranny.” These buzzwords don’t just describe—they indict. By focusing on the riots’ brutality—pregnant women killed, homes razed—they tap a global playbook: victimhood trumps aggression every time. Godhra’s 59 dead? A footnote, if that. The left knows the world doesn’t linger on who struck first—it fixates on who bled most. And they’re right—optics rule.

This isn’t new. The left has honed this for decades. In India, they’ve spun colonial history into a tale of eternal Hindu guilt, downplaying Islamic invasions while amplifying caste sins. Globally, they’ve turned Israel into a pariah while Hamas gets a pass. Words like “justice” and “equality” become battering rams—noble on the surface, selective underneath. Empuraan’s cuts—17 scenes trimmed under pressure—prove the game’s finesse: cry censorship, claim moral victory, keep the narrative alive. Kerala’s left government backing it? That’s the cherry—state-sanctioned “truth” with a halo.

The Right’s Honest Rage: A Fist Without a Voice

The right, meanwhile, swings hard but stumbles. Godhra’s 59 dead aren’t just numbers to them—they’re a wound, a call to arms. The riots? Retribution, not aggression. To them, Empuraan isn’t art—it’s a slap, erasing their pain to spotlight their fists. So they hit back: boycotts, hashtags, threats. X lights up with #EmpuraanControversy, ticket stubs burned online, RSS mouthpieces like Organiser screaming “anti-Hindu agenda.” They’re not wrong about the film’s tilt—30 minutes of riots versus Godhra’s blink-and-miss—it’s lopsided as hell. But their response? Loud, raw, and sloppy.

Here’s their Achilles’ heel: they don’t know the game. The left cloaks bias in nuance; the right roars facts without polish. “Muslims started it!” they shout, pointing to Godhra’s ashes. True—but the world hears “rape” and “pogrom” louder. They lack the left’s finesse—phrases like “Hindu unity” or “strong retaliation” could frame their stand, but they don’t wield them. Instead, they’re stuck defending, not defining. The left says “fascism”; the right says “no, we’re not”—and loses the plot. They’re honest—59 dead sparked 1,000 more, and they’ll own it—but honesty without strategy is a punching bag.

America’s Mirror: The Right’s Same Blind Spot

Look at the U.S. post-9/11. Al-Qaeda killed 2,977; America flattened Afghanistan (46,000+ civilian deaths) and Iraq (200,000+). No one asked how many Afghans attacked first—zero—because the West framed it: “war on terror,” “defending freedom.” Brutal? Yes. Effective? Damn right. India’s right doesn’t get this. They could say “Hindu survival” or “retribution for Godhra,” but they don’t. They’re caught in the left’s trap—reacting, not shaping. The U.S. didn’t apologize for collateral damage; India’s right chokes on it, letting “rape” drown “resolve.”

The Cost: Truth Buried, Right Vilified

Empuraan’s fallout proves it. The left’s narrative—Hindu aggression, Muslim victims—sticks. The right’s truth—Godhra’s dead, a people’s rage—fades. They’re not wrong to call out the film’s distortion, but they’re outgunned. The left’s words paint them as brutes; their own flailing makes it stick. Mohanlal’s apology? A win for optics, not facts. The right’s fury burns hot, but it’s the left’s sly tongue that brands the story.

The Fix: Learn or Lose

India’s right needs to wake up. Honesty’s great—59 dead, 1,000 back—but it’s useless without a frame. Call it “Hindu defiance” or “justice for Godhra”—own the retaliation, not the guilt. The left’s propaganda thrives on half-truths; the right’s strength is the whole damn thing. They don’t need to mimic the left’s sanctimony—just outtalk it. Until then, they’ll stay the villain, not because they’re wrong, but because they’re outplayed. Truth’s one face, but it’s the loudest voice that wins.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views or official stance of Realshepower. This content is intended for informational and discussion purposes only and does not constitute professional advice or an endorsement by Realshepower.